The Guardian correspondent notes mockery of justice in Khashoggi case

The Guardian correspondent notes mockery

Turkish reaction

Ankara used the killing to exert pressure on its Saudi regional rivals, drip-feeding lurid details to the media and sharing damning audio recordings of the murder with other governments.

Fred Ryan, the publisher and chief executive of the Washington Post, for whom Khashoggi wrote a column about foreign affairs, said: “The complete lack of transparency and the Saudi government’s refusal to cooperate with independent investigators suggests that this was merely a sham trial.”

However, the verdicts were cautiously greeted as “an important step” by a senior official in Donald Trump’s administration, who spoke to Reuters on condition of anonymity.

US defended ally

The US president has condemned the killing, but defended his ally Prince Mohammed despite fierce criticism from Congress and members of his own party.

Saudi Arabia is the cornerstone of Trump’s Middle East policy and the president is unwilling to forgo trade or diplomatic ties with the oil-rich kingdom.

Khashoggi, a member of the Saudi elite, broke with the powerful royal family and moved to the US in 2017, where he became a vocal critic of the country as a columnist for the Washington Post.

He visited the Saudi consulate in Istanbul on 2 October last year to pick up paperwork for his forthcoming marriage to his Turkish fiancee, Hatice Cengiz, and was never seen again.

The Guardian correspondent notes mockery

Riyadh initially denied it had anything to do with Khashoggi’s disappearance.

However, under pressure from sustained leaks from Turkish intelligence that suggested high-level Saudi involvement, the kingdom eventually admitted government agents carried out the killing, offering a series of shifting explanations.

The 59-year-old’s body has not been found and is thought by Turkish investigators to have been dismembered with a bone saw and then dissolved in acid.

According to Callamard’s independent investigation, which was published in June this year, a team of 15 Saudi agents – including a forensics doctor, intelligence and security officers and individuals who worked for the crown prince’s office – flew to Turkey hours earlier to meet Khashoggi inside the consulate.

On a purported audio recording from inside the consulate two Saudi officials were heard discussing how to cut up and transport Khashoggi’s body before he entered.

MBS image tarnished

Prince Mohammed, who has cultivated an image of liberal reformer, emerged particularly tarnished after questions were raised over how such an operation could have been carried out without his consent or knowledge.

While the prince is popular at home for implementing wide-ranging social reforms, since his appointment as heir to the throne in 2017 he has also cracked down on dissent.

Hundreds of people who pose a threat to his financial or political supremacy have been detained and tried on national security grounds, including high-profile women’s rights campaigners and international business figures.

Even CIA, Western intelligence blame MBS

The CIA, along with several western governments, eventually concluded that the crown prince himself ordered Khashoggi’s assassination.

The kingdom has instead blamed rogue agents who it says took a repatriation mission too far.

As well as his former royal adviser and key ally Qahtani, two other senior figures were cleared of wrongdoing: the former deputy intelligence chief, Ahmed al-Asiri, was tried but released due to insufficient evidence; and Mohammed al-Otaibi, the Saudi consul-general in Istanbul at the time of Khashoggi’s death, who was found not guilty.

Callamard’s investigation, published in June, identified the five people facing the death penalty as Fahad Shabib Albalawi, Turki Muserref Alshehri and Waleed Abdullah Alshehri, as well as Maher Abdulaziz Mutreb, an intelligence officer believed to work for Qahtani, and Salah Mohammed Tubaigy, a forensic doctor with the interior ministry.

UN report

According to the UN report the other six defendants were Asiri, Mansour Othman Abahussain, Mohammed Saad Alzahrani, Mustafa Mohammed Almadani, Saif Saad Alqahtani and Muflih Shaya Almuslih, reportedly a member of the consulate’s staff.

In total 21 people were arrested and 10 more called for questioning, the public prosecutor’s office said. No other details were immediately given about the rulings in the highly secretive trial, which began in January and was conducted over nine sessions.

The identities of the convicted men were not immediately confirmed by Saudi officials. Most observers, including UN investigators, have been repeatedly barred from hearings, although a handful of diplomats, including from Turkey, as well as members of Khashoggi’s family, were allowed to attend the sessions.

The death penalty in Saudi Arabia is carried out by beheading. The convicted defendants may appeal against the preliminary verdicts, the prosecutor’s office said.

The Guardian correspondent notes mockery

Cengiz said the announcement was “not acceptable”. “As we will never forget you, we will not forget your murderers, and also those who are trying to cover up your murder,” she wrote on Twitter.

The son thanks Kingdom

Salah, one of Khashoggi’s sons, said his family had achieved justice thanks to the verdict of Saudi Arabia’s public prosecutor.

According to the Washington Post, the journalist’s four adult children have received payments and property from the royal family as blood money in lieu of a public apology.

Pictures of the grieving Salah shaking Prince Mohammed’s hand after being summoned to a royal palace in Riyadh in the weeks following his father’s death were widely condemned as a ruthless photo opportunity.