Nancy Guthrie Missing: Was Pizza Delivered at Kidnapping Scene? Jonathan Lee Riches Draws Scrutiny

TUCSON, Arizona – February 24, 2026: The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, mother of Today Show anchor Savannah Guthrie, continues to attract national attention. Now, a strange pizza delivery at her Tucson home has added another layer of controversy to the ongoing investigation.

Nancy, 84, has been missing since January 31, 2026. Authorities say the case remains active. The Pima County Sheriff’s Department and the Federal Bureau of Investigation are leading the probe.

Doorbell Footage and Early Leads

Earlier in the investigation, officials released doorbell camera footage showing a masked man near Nancy’s front door. The individual appeared to be wearing a grey shirt, black pants, and carrying a large black bag. Investigators described him as a person of interest.

Authorities asked the public and media to avoid interfering with the scene. Despite this, unexpected incidents continued to unfold outside the property.

Domino’s Pizza Delivered to Crime Scene

In a surprising moment, a Domino’s Pizza delivery driver was seen walking up to Nancy Guthrie’s front door carrying multiple pizza boxes.

Journalist Ford Hatchett later stated that the delivery was intended for someone in the media covering the case. According to a report by The Guardian, the pizzas were reportedly ordered by a viewer for YouTuber Jonathan Lee Riches, who was live-streaming near the home at the time.

Social media footage showed the driver approaching the residence before realizing the situation. Officials later expressed concern over food deliveries being sent directly to an active investigation site.

Sheriff’s Warning to Media

The Pima County Sheriff’s Department issued a public statement urging media and content creators not to order food to the crime scene address. Officials said such actions disrupt police operations and interfere with active investigative work.

Authorities stressed that private property laws must also be respected.

Who Is Jonathan Lee Riches?

Jonathan Lee Riches runs a YouTube channel called JLR Investigates, which has over 500,000 subscribers. He is known for live-streaming high-profile criminal trials and investigations.

According to past reporting by The Guardian, Riches previously served prison time for wire fraud and has filed thousands of lawsuits in the past, many of which were dismissed.

In recent weeks, Riches has streamed from outside Nancy Guthrie’s home. Some online users have accused him of spreading misleading information. Others say a viewer ordered the pizza without his knowledge.

There is no official confirmation that Riches ordered the pizza himself. Law enforcement has not charged him in connection with the incident.

Investigation Still Ongoing

Despite online debates, authorities continue focusing on evidence collection and forensic testing. Officials have reminded the public that speculation and interference can slow progress in sensitive cases.

Nancy Guthrie’s whereabouts remain unknown. Law enforcement says anyone with verified information should contact authorities directly.

The case remains one of the most closely followed missing-person investigations in Arizona this year.