Who is Kylee Anderson? Benson Boone Accused of Cheating Amid Viral TikTok

Maggie Thurmon, social media personality and ex-girlfriend of pop singer Benson Boone, has sparked speculation surrounding the reason for their recent breakup. In a TikTok video posted weeks after their reported split in September 2025, Thurmon appeared to subtly reference infidelity, leading fans to connect the dots.

The video featured Thurmon lip-syncing to a clip from The Office, in which Pam asks Kelly Kapoor if she remembers what it felt like when Ryan cheated on her. Kelly responds: “Which time?” The audio choice, combined with the timing of the post, quickly drew attention, with many assuming it hinted at personal parallels in Thurmon’s own relationship.

One viewer commented that if Boone had cheated, they would “turn the car around.” Thurmon allegedly replied: “Put your blinker on babe.” The comment, though unconfirmed, only fueled further speculation.

The conversation in the comments section eventually turned to Kylee Anderson, a singer and childhood friend of Benson Boone from Utah. Following Boone and Thurmon’s split and mutual unfollowing on Instagram, Anderson was reportedly unfollowed by both as well.

Anderson released a song titled Benny in August 2025. The track’s lyrics describe falling in love with a best friend and sharing a romantic moment. Anderson allegedly commented on the song, writing:
“My experience with my best friend who I fell in love with and he ended up getting a gf and expected me to be friends with her.”

This statement further intensified online rumors suggesting Anderson may have been involved in the couple’s breakup. However, it’s important to note that neither Anderson, Boone, nor Thurmon has directly addressed the cheating speculation. As of now, all claims remain unconfirmed and are based solely on internet speculation.

On October 6, 2025, Thurmon responded to the growing fan discourse in another TikTok comment, explaining that she felt overwhelmed by the attention surrounding her breakup. She wrote:
“I got overwhelmed. I’ve always been a more private online person, tonight I remembered why. Thank you to everyone who was sending love, I appreciate yall so much.”

Meanwhile, Benson Boone may have briefly acknowledged the emotional impact of the breakup during his American Heart Tour performance at Nashville’s Bridgestone Arena. Prior to singing In the Stars, Boone shared a heartfelt message about loss and moving forward.

“Sometimes people leave your life. Whether it’s the right thing or the wrong thing, and it is always hard, always, every single time. And it sucks. And it sucks to sit in it, and it sucks to be sad about it, and it sucks to feel that so hard sometimes. But it’s okay, it’s life. It happens,” Boone said, without naming anyone directly.

Boone’s American Heart Tour is scheduled to conclude on November 18, 2025. Fans continue to follow the story closely, awaiting any potential statements from the involved parties.