American Idol Winner Jamal Roberts Addresses Carrie Underwood’s ‘Unhappy’ Finale Reaction

Jamal Roberts, the newly crowned American Idol champion, has responded to fan speculation about judge Carrie Underwood’s seemingly “unhappy” reaction during his season finale win.

The Controversial Moment

• Viewers noted Carrie, 42, appeared stoic when Jamal, 27, was announced as winner
• Some fans claimed she hesitated to stand during his final performance
• Online debates erupted, with critics calling her “unsupportive” compared to fellow judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie

Jamal’s Candid Response

At the BET 45th Anniversary Dinner, Jamal addressed the backlash:

• “Carrie is a country singer and she likes country music… I don’t think she likes every genre for real.”
• Acknowledged she had “her picks” but added: “I feel like the better person won.”
• Defended her honesty: “We applaud her for sticking to her roots.”

Fan Reactions Split

Critics:

• “She told Jamal to move more but not others—unfair!”
• “Carrie hating until the very end I see.”

Supporters:

• “False controversy! She gave constructive criticism to ALL.”
• “She congratulated Jamal on X—people are overreacting.”

Carrie’s Official Stance

Despite the drama, the season 4 winner publicly praised Jamal post-show:

• “Congratulations to the newest winner of @AmericanIdol!… He’s going to do great things.”

Will Carrie Return as Judge?

Insiders reveal:

• Producers “love Carrie” and want her back
• She’s reportedly “on the fence” after a “bumpy” first season
• Decision expected soon before next season’s filming